ChatGPT Prompt To Critically Review A Proposal

Critically review the attached proposal as a skeptical but constructive decision-maker. State the proposal's objective and requested decision in two sentences. Identify up to seven consequential weaknesses, ranked by likely effect on the outcome. For each, cite the relevant section or a short excerpt, distinguish observed facts from your inference, explain the failure mechanism and recommend a practical correction. Examine assumptions, evidence quality, costs, ownership, dependencies, feasibility, alternatives and success measures. Do not manufacture objections or treat missing information as proof that an assumption is false. Give the strongest case in favor of the proposal, then state whether it is ready for approval, needs revision or lacks enough evidence for a decision. Finish with five questions whose answers would most change that assessment.